Published: March 01, 2010
For baby-boomers, there is both good news and bad news about the cognitive health of the aging brain.
Brain researcher Gary Small from UCLA conveys the bad news first: "Reaction time is slower," he says. "It takes us longer to learn new information. Sometimes it takes us longer to retrieve information, so we have that tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon — where you almost have that word or that thought. That's typical of the middle-age brain."
As we age, our ability to multi-task diminishes. "We're quick, but we're sloppy when we're in middle-age. We make more errors when we're in middle age," says Small.
The Older, But Wiser, Brain
But Small has found that it's not all bad news. He points to a continued improvement in complex reasoning skills as we enter middle age. Small suggests that this increase may be due to a process in the brain called "myelination." Myelin is the insulation wrapped around brain cells that increases their conductivity — the speed with which information travels from brain cell to brain cell. And the myelination doesn't reach its peak until middle age. By this point, says Small, "the neuro-circuits fire more rapidly, as if you're going from dial-up to DSL." Complex reasoning skills improve, and we're able to anticipate problems and reason things out better than when we were young.
And, Small adds, there's another area of improvement as we age: empathy — the ability to understand the emotional point of view of another. Empathy increases as we age.
'Your Brain On Google'
One of the great discoveries from recent neuroscience research is that the human brain is always changing, from moment to moment and throughout life. It continues to develop, and even continues to grow new brain cells.
"An old myth in neuroscience," says Small, "is that once a brain cell dies off you can't replace it." But many studies have now shown, he adds, that there is, in fact, brain cell growth throughout life. So, he says, the brain can continue to learn throughout the middle age years and beyond.
In a recent study that Small refers to as "your brain on Google," healthy, middle-aged volunteers, all novices on the computer, were taught how to do a Google search. They were told then to practice doing online searches for an hour a day, for seven days. After the week's practice, the volunteers came back into Small's lab and had their brains scanned while doing a Google search.
The scans revealed significant increases in brain activity in the areas that control memory and decision-making.
"The area of the brain that showed the increases was the frontal lobe, the thinking brain, especially in areas that control decision making and working memory," Small says. One interpretation of his findings, he says, is that with practice, a middle-age brain can very quickly alter its neuron-circuitry, can strengthen the neuron circuits that control short-term memory and decision making.
Physical Fitness Helps Brain, Too
Research by neuroscientist Art Kramer, from the University of Illinois, highlights the plasticity — the ability to grow and change — of the aging brain. In his studies on physical exercise, Kramer has found that memory can improve with treadmill workouts.
"Over a six-month to one-year period," Kramer says, "three days a week, working up to an hour a day, people improved in various aspects of both short-term and long-term memory."
After treadmill training, the "aging couch potatoes," as Kramer calls them, were given brain scans. Those who'd trained had larger hippocampi, the brain area key for memory. Other brain regions too — central for decision-making, planning and multi-tasking — were also larger in the treadmill exercisers. "There are a number of regions," says Kramer, "that on MRI scans tend to show not just stability but increases as a function of exercise in middle-age and older brains."
Such research studies underscore that both physical exercise and cognitive brain training contribute to brain health. And these two scientists not only talk the talk, they also, quite literally, walk the walk. Kramer, 56, goes to the gym four or five days a week, getting aerobic exercise on a stationary bike and strength training by lifting weights. Small, 58, does a New York Times crossword and numbers puzzle every morning, as well as a series of toning and stretching exercises and at least 20 minutes of aerobic exercise each day. [Copyright 2013 NPR]
MICHELLE TRUDEAU: I'm Michelle Trudeau. Just as in adolescence, there's good news and bad news about the brain in middle age, and ways researchers tell us to maintain good brain health. First, the bad news for us middle-agers.
Dr. GARY SMALL (Director, UCLA Center on Aging): Reaction time is slower. It takes us longer to learn new information.
TRUDEAU: That's research psychiatrist Gary Small, from UCLA.
Dr. SMALL: Sometimes it takes us longer to retrieve information, so we have that tip-of-the-tongue phenomenon. That's typical of a middle-age brain.
TRUDEAU: Any more bad news?
Dr. SMALL: We're not so great at multi-tasking. We're quick, but we're sloppy. We make more errors when we're middle-aged.
TRUDEAU: Is there any good news?
Dr. SMALL: Complex reasoning is very good when we get older, as we age.
TRUDEAU: Small explains that myelination, the insulation wrapped around each nerve cell that increases conductivity, reaches its maximum in middle age.
Dr. SMALL: So that means that the neural circuits fire more rapidly, so you're going from dial-up to DSL.
TRUDEAU: And Small adds empathy to our plus column.
Dr. SMALL: If you design an experiment, and you present several options for a young person, they're more likely to choose a more narcissistic option than one that tends to take into account the other person's interest and point of view than, say, a middle-age or older person would.
TRUDEAU: One of the great discoveries from recent neuroscience research is that our brains are always changing, always developing, even able to grow new brain cells.
In a recent study, one he calls "Your Brain on Google," Gary Small trained healthy, middle-aged folks who were novices on the computer to do Google searches. They practiced searching online an hour a day for a week, and then came back into the lab for brain scans. The scans showed significant increases in brain activity in the areas that control memory and decision-making.
Dr. SMALL: One interpretation of that is that with practice, very quickly, an older brain can alter its neural circuitry, can strengthen those neural circuits controlling working memory, controlling decision-making areas of the brain.
TRUDEAU: Research by neuroscientist Art Kramer, at the University of Illinois, demonstrates the plasticity, or the ability to grow and change, of the aging brain. In his studies on physical exercise, memory improves with aerobic, treadmill training.
Dr. ART KRAMER (Neuroscientist, University of Illinois): So what we find is that over a six-month to a one-year period, at three days a week, working up to an hour a day, that people improve in various aspects of both short-term and long-term memory.
TRUDEAU: And people who exercised had larger hippocampi, a critical memory center. Other brain areas, too central for decision-making, planning and multi-tasking were also larger, larger than when they began the aerobic exercise program.
Dr. KRAMER: There are number of regions that on MRI scans tend to show not just stability, but increases as a function of exercise in middle-age and older brains.
TRUDEAU: And these scientists are walking the walk. For all you baby boomers out there with middle-aged brains, heres what Dr. Kramer, age 56 and next, Dr. Small, age 58, do to keep their own brains healthy.
Dr. KRAMER: Before this interview, I was over at the gym, and I was riding a stationary bike and reading a few newspapers. And I was also lifting weights.
Dr. SMALL: And I'll start out in the New York Times, and I'll do "KenKen." And then either Ill solve it, or I get to the point where I screwed it up. And then I move on the crossword. That's my typical day.
For NPR News, I'm Michelle Trudeau. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.